TrueStory Africa Work with us

118 · Insights · Strategy

How to evaluate creative proposals: a scoring guide for procurement teams

For procurement and communications teams who must compare agency proposals fairly, this guide gives a scoring method, sample weights and a sheet you can copy.

  • Published5 November 2026
  • Reading time7 min
  • ByTrueStory Africa
  • Sources6
  • Facts checked27 October 2026

Why creative proposals are hard to score

A creative proposal is not like a quote for laptops. Two agencies can offer the same deliverables, a three-minute film and 40 edited photos, and produce very different results. That is why teams often struggle to evaluate creative proposals in a way that is both fair and useful.

The answer is to score what predicts a good outcome: how well the bidder understood the problem, how they plan to solve it, who will do the work, and whether the price is realistic. A clear method also protects the procurement team. If a losing bidder asks why, you can show them.

Public bodies in Rwanda work under Law N° 031/2022 governing public procurement, which requires public bodies to follow standard procedures and use electronic procurement, with principles such as transparency, competition and cost-effectiveness.1 When the bill was before Parliament in 2022, its stated aims included a clear bid evaluation process that leads to the determination of value for money.2 A good scoring guide puts those principles into practice for creative services.

Set the criteria before you see any bids

Criteria and the guidance for applying them should be written together and finalised before the request for proposals is released.3 Put them, with their weights, in the request itself so bidders know what matters and evaluators apply them in the same way.

For communications and creative work, five criteria cover most needs:

  • Understanding of the brief: do they grasp the audience, the purpose and the context, including language and sensitivity?
  • Approach and methodology: is the creative and production plan clear, realistic and right for the audience?
  • Team: the named people who will direct, shoot, write and edit, and their relevant experience.
  • Relevant past work: samples that are similar in subject, scale and format.
  • Ethics and compliance: consent, safeguarding, accessibility and data handling.

Write a short description of what a low, middle and high score looks like for each criterion. Without this, one evaluator's seven is another's four.

Score what predicts a good outcome: understanding, approach, the people who will do the work, and a realistic price.

Key point

How to weight quality and cost

Most multilateral procurement for consultancy services uses a combined quality and cost method. Under the World Bank's consultant guidelines, the request for proposals must state the weights, and cost normally carries 20 points out of 100, with quality carrying the rest.4 The same guidelines suggest indicative ranges for technical criteria: methodology 20 to 50 points and key experts 30 to 60 points, with more weight on both for complex work.4

Those ranges are a useful starting point for creative services, because the methodology and the people are what you are really buying. A typical split for a documentary or campaign might look like this:

  • Understanding of the brief: 15
  • Approach and methodology: 30
  • Team: 30
  • Relevant past work: 15
  • Ethics and compliance: 10

Set a minimum technical score as well. The World Bank guidelines give an indicative range of 70 to 85 out of 100 and reject proposals that fall below it.4 This stops a weak but cheap bid from winning on price alone. Your own rules, or your funder's, take priority over these examples.

Running a fair evaluation

Use a small panel. The World Bank guidelines describe a committee of at least three and normally no more than seven members, each scoring proposals independently before a joint report is written.4 Include at least one person who knows the subject and one who understands production.

A sound process looks like this:

  • Each evaluator declares any conflict of interest before reading bids.
  • Each evaluator scores alone, and writes one or two sentences of evidence for every score.
  • The panel meets to compare scores and discuss large gaps, not to average them blindly.
  • The financial proposals are opened only after technical scores are agreed.
  • The chair records the final scores and the reasons in a short report.

Numbers alone do not make an evaluation objective. US federal transit guidance warns that weights and formulas do not replace reasoned judgement, and asks evaluators to record strengths, weaknesses and risks behind each rating.3 Those written reasons are what you will rely on in a debrief or an audit.

Related service

Strategic communications

Media relations, key messages and spokesperson preparation that help your organisation speak clearly when it matters.

Avoid asking for free creative work

It is tempting to ask bidders for a full script, a storyboard or sample designs. This is speculative work, often called spec work, and it rarely helps you choose. AIGA, the professional association for design, notes that little time, energy and thought can go into speculative work, and that it can create intellectual property risks for both sides.5

Ask instead for a short written approach, a treatment of one or two pages, relevant past work and the named team. If you need to see creative thinking, shortlist two or three bidders and pay them a fixed fee for a short concept stage.

The UK advertising industry's Pitch Positive Pledge, launched in 2022, asks clients to be sure a pitch is necessary, to consider the implications of what they ask for, and to tell every agency the outcome directly with feedback.6 These are sensible habits for any organisation buying creative services.

Red flags and good signs

Some signs are easy to miss when you are reading ten proposals in an afternoon.

  • A generic approach that could apply to any client. Look for evidence they read your brief.
  • A team that is not named, or senior people in the proposal who will not be on set.
  • A price far below the others. Check what has been left out, such as travel, captions, translation or licensed music.
  • No mention of consent or safeguarding when the work involves filming communities or children.
  • Past work that is not theirs or not similar. Ask what role they played.

Good signs include clear questions back to you, a realistic timeline, and honest notes on risks such as weather, permits or approval time. In our own practice, we find the most useful proposals are the ones that challenge one assumption in the brief.

A scoring sheet you can copy

Copy this sheet into a spreadsheet, with one tab per evaluator and one summary tab.

  • Pass or fail checks: eligibility documents, signed declarations, deadline met, all required sections present.
  • Understanding of the brief (15): audience, purpose, context and languages. Evidence note.
  • Approach and methodology (30): creative idea, production plan, schedule, risk plan. Evidence note.
  • Team (30): named lead, crew and editor, relevant experience, local knowledge and language skills. Evidence note.
  • Relevant past work (15): two or three similar samples, role played. Evidence note.
  • Ethics and compliance (10): consent forms, child safeguarding, captions and accessibility, data storage. Evidence note.
  • Technical total (100) and whether it passes the minimum score you set.
  • Financial score: for passing bids only. Check the price covers every deliverable in the brief.
  • Combined score: technical and financial scores multiplied by their published weights and added together.
  • Decision and reasons: two or three sentences the chair can share in a debrief.

Keep the completed sheets with the procurement file. A clear record is the best answer to any later question about the award.

Questions people ask

What weight should price have when evaluating creative proposals?

Many development procurement rules give quality most of the weight. The World Bank's consultant guidelines normally set cost at 20 out of 100. Always follow your own rules or your funder's first.

Should we ask agencies for a free concept or storyboard?

It is better not to. Unpaid concepts are produced quickly and tell you little about how the agency works. Ask for a short approach and past work, or pay a shortlist for a concept stage.

How many people should be on an evaluation panel?

The World Bank's consultant guidelines call for at least three members and normally no more than seven. Each person should score alone first, record reasons, and declare any conflict of interest.

What is a minimum technical score?

It is the lowest quality score a proposal must reach before its price is considered. It stops a weak but cheap bid from winning on price alone.

Sources

Every numbered link in this article points to one of these sources. We checked each one in October 2026. Summaries of rules are for planning, not legal advice.

  1. 1

    UNEP Law and Environment Assistance Platform (FAOLEX record). Law N° 031/2022 Governing Public Procurement (Rwanda).

    Official sourceleap.unep.orgChecked 27 October 2026

  2. 2

    KT Press. Rwanda adopts new procurement bill to improve tender procedures.

    Secondary sourcektpress.rwChecked 27 October 2026

  3. 3

    US Federal Transit Administration. Proposal Evaluation (Frequently Asked Questions).

    Official sourcetransit.dot.govChecked 27 October 2026

  4. 4
  5. 5

    AIGA. AIGA position on spec work.

    Secondary sourceaiga.orgChecked 27 October 2026

  6. 6

    IPA. IPA and ISBA launch Pitch Positive Pledge to improve pitching behaviours.

    Secondary sourceipa.co.ukChecked 27 October 2026

Found a mistake? Email hello@truestoryafrica.com and we will correct it. How we check facts

Related service

Strategic communications

Media relations, key messages and spokesperson preparation that help your organisation speak clearly when it matters.

Let’s tell
the story well

Launching a policy, reporting to partners, hosting a summit or explaining a programme? We shape the message, find the human story and make it clear.

Download our company profilePDF · 42 pages · 6 MB

TrueStory Africa

presents

Real stories. Clear impact

Strategy & story
TrueStory Africa
Aerial
Fiston Nyirishema
Photography
Yuhi Irakiza Augustin
Laury Habyarimana
Video production
Hakizimana Shaban
Cinematography
Isaac Gisubizo
Benjamin Irihose
Writing
Aliane Karerangabo
Filmed in
Rwanda and across Africa
Consent
Kinyarwanda & English
Headquarters
KG 522 St, Kigali

Every photograph on this website was taken by TrueStory Africa, with consent.
No scenes were staged in the making of this website.

Share this