137 · Insights · Strategy
Questions to ask before you approve a creative concept
For managers and communications leads who sign off campaigns, films and designs, a short set of questions that catch problems while they are still cheap to fix.
Why the approval stage matters
A creative concept is the central idea behind a campaign, film or design: the message, the tone, the visual approach and how it will reach people. It is usually presented as a few frames, a script outline, mood images or a short treatment.
The moment you approve a creative concept is the cheapest moment to change it. After approval, the team books crew, casts contributors, travels and designs. Every change after that costs time and money. A short, structured review now prevents expensive rewrites later.
The questions below work for a social media campaign, a documentary, an annual report cover or an event identity. Use the ones that fit.
Does it answer the brief?
Start with the creative brief you agreed. A concept can be beautiful and still miss the point. Ask:
- What is this for? Name the one change you want: awareness, a behaviour, a donation, a policy decision.
- Who is it for? A concept made for ministers will not work the same way for young people on TikTok.
- What is the single message? If the team cannot say it in one sentence, the audience will not remember it.
- How will we know it worked? Agree the measures now, not after launch.
If you find yourself saying "I just don't like it", pause. Try to name what is wrong in terms of the brief. Personal taste is a weak reason to reject work, and a poor guide to what your audience will respond to.
The moment you approve a concept is the cheapest moment to change it.
Will the audience understand it?
Teams who have lived with a project for months are the worst judges of whether outsiders will understand it. The simplest protection is to show the concept to a few people from the intended audience.
The US National Cancer Institute's planning guide for health communication says that getting feedback from intended audiences when developing messages and materials is crucial for the success of every communication programme.1 It advises pretesting messages and materials with people who share the attributes of the intended audience, and choosing pretesting methods that fit the budget and timeline.1
This does not have to be a large study. A handful of honest conversations can reveal a confusing phrase, an image that means something different locally, or a joke that does not translate. In Rwanda, check the concept in each language you will use, not only in English.
Is it ethical and respectful?
Any concept that shows real people, especially in development or humanitarian work, needs an ethics check before approval. The Dóchas Code of Conduct on Images and Messages, on which the 2023 Dóchas Guide to Ethical Communications builds, rests on respect for the dignity of the people concerned, belief in the equality of all people, and acceptance of the need to promote fairness, solidarity and justice.2
The code also gives you practical questions to ask:2
- Does it show the situation truthfully, in its immediate and wider context?
- Could it stereotype, sensationalise or discriminate against people, situations or places?
- Will the people shown take part with full understanding and give their permission, and can they choose not to be identified?
- Do the people represented have the opportunity to tell their own stories?
If children appear, check the plan against UNICEF's ethical reporting guidelines. They say the dignity and rights of every child must be respected in every circumstance, and that no story or image should be published that might put the child, siblings or peers at risk.3
Bond's 2024 guidelines go further. They state that NGO imagery of brown and black people suffering and in need of "saving" has created and perpetuated racism, and that the value of anti-racism must be upheld in the way content is produced.4 A concept built on a "saviour" story should be sent back, however striking it looks.
Related service
Strategic communications
Media relations, key messages and spokesperson preparation that help your organisation speak clearly when it matters.
Can it be made and delivered?
A strong idea that cannot be made on time is a weak idea. Ask the creative team to walk you through how the concept becomes the finished work:
- What locations, contributors, permits and travel does it need?
- Does the timeline include consent, translation and approval rounds?
- Does it work in every format you need: wide screen, vertical video, print, a slide?
- Will it still work in Kinyarwanda, French or Kiswahili, or does it depend on an English pun?
- Are the music, fonts and stock images licensed for your use?
Accessibility belongs here too. For text on screen or in print, the W3C's WCAG standard sets a minimum contrast ratio of 4.5:1 for normal text and 3:1 for large text.5 For video, plan accurate captions from the start. The W3C warns that automatically generated captions do not meet user needs or accessibility requirements unless they are confirmed to be fully accurate.6 Ask whether the colours, captions and type sizes in the concept will meet these standards.
Who needs to sign it off?
Many concepts are approved by one person, then blocked weeks later by someone else: a director, a donor, a partner or a legal team. Before you approve, list everyone who must agree and what each will check.
Common reviewers include leadership for tone and positioning, programme staff for accuracy, safeguarding leads for any work with children or vulnerable people, and donors for visibility and branding rules. In our own practice, we ask for one consolidated set of comments per round. It avoids contradictory feedback and keeps the schedule intact.
A concept sign-off template
Copy this into your approval email or form. Answer each question with yes, no or a short note.
- Purpose: does the concept serve the one goal in the brief?
- Audience: is it clearly made for the people named in the brief?
- Message: can we state the main message in one sentence?
- Understanding: have a few people from the audience seen it, and did they understand it?
- Accuracy: are facts, figures and claims correct and sourced?
- Dignity: are people shown with respect and context, without stereotypes?
- Consent: is there a plan for informed consent and anonymity where needed?
- Safeguarding: if children or vulnerable adults appear, is the plan approved?
- Feasibility: can it be made on the agreed budget and timeline?
- Formats and languages: does it work in every format and language we need?
- Accessibility: will captions, contrast and type sizes meet accessibility standards?
- Approvals: has everyone who must sign off seen it?
Record the decision, the date and any conditions, such as "approved subject to new title". That record helps if questions arise later.
Questions people ask
What is a creative concept?
It is the central idea behind a campaign, film or design, covering the message, tone and visual approach. It is usually shown as sketches, mood images, a script outline or a short treatment before production starts.
How many concepts should an agency present?
There is no fixed rule. Two or three distinct routes are common, but one well-argued concept that clearly answers the brief can be enough.
Should we test a concept before approving it?
Yes, if you can. Getting feedback from people in your intended audience while messages and materials are still in development often reveals confusing words or images before money is spent on production.1
How do we give useful feedback on a concept?
Link each comment to the brief, say what the problem is rather than prescribing the fix, and send one consolidated set of comments from all reviewers.
Sources
Every numbered link in this article points to one of these sources. We checked each one in October 2026. Summaries of rules are for planning, not legal advice.
- 1
US National Cancer Institute. Making Health Communication Programs Work (Pink Book).
Official sourcecancer.govChecked 27 October 2026
- 2
Dóchas. The Dóchas Guide to Ethical Communications.
Secondary sourcedochas.ieChecked 27 October 2026
- 3
UNICEF. Ethical reporting guidelines: Key principles for responsible reporting on children and young people.
Official sourceunicef.orgChecked 27 October 2026
- 4
Bond. Putting the people in the pictures first (2024 updated version).
Secondary sourcebond.org.ukChecked 27 October 2026
- 5
W3C Web Accessibility Initiative. Understanding Success Criterion 1.4.3: Contrast (Minimum).
Official sourcew3.orgChecked 27 October 2026
- 6
W3C Web Accessibility Initiative (WAI). Captions/Subtitles (2024).
Official sourcew3.orgChecked 27 October 2026
Found a mistake? Email hello@truestoryafrica.com and we will correct it. How we check facts
Related service
Strategic communications
Media relations, key messages and spokesperson preparation that help your organisation speak clearly when it matters.
01 · Insights
Keep reading
How to write a creative brief for a film or photo shoot
What to put in a video or photography brief so the production team delivers what you need, on time and without surprises.
Read the articleHow NGOs can tell stories without exploiting vulnerable communities
Practical principles for photographs and films that show real change while protecting the dignity of the people in them.
Read the articleKey messages and the message house: a simple method
Build one core message, three supporting pillars and the proof beneath them, so everyone in your organisation tells the same story.
Read the article